11/7/2009

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     Thanks for Attending the October 24, 2009 Meetings with the Deputy Under Secretary of Agriculture!    We had an excellent turnout at the October 24th meeting at the Elgin School sponsored by Representative Gabrielle Giffords with Jay Jensen, the Deputy Under Secretary of Agriculture.  Thanks so much attending, and special thanks to those who made presentations and comments.   At the Green Valley meeting later in the day Tohono O'Odham Nation Chairman Ned Norris Jr. announced that  the Nation's Legislative council opposes the mine, noting that the land was home to ancestral burial grounds of the Tohono and of their ancestors, the HoHoKam.     Letter from Secretary of Agriculture Thomas Vislack Concerning the No Action Alternative   On October 23, 2009 Secretary of Agriculture, Thomas Vislack, sent a letter to Congresswoman Giffords responding to her concerns about a recent Forest Service interpretation of its ability to consider a no action altermative for the proposed Rosemont Mine.  The letter states in part (emphasis added):   "The Forest Service is reviewing the issues surrounding the Rosemont Project as part of its obligations under the National Environmental Policy Act.  As part of that review, the Forest Service is examining both the proposed mine and a no-action alternative in its environmental impact statement.  No decisions have been made with respect to issuing a record of decision for the proposed mine and none will be made until we have completed a thorough review of the proposed mine, the mine plan of operation and any required mitigation."   The full text of the letter can be found at: http://www.hiltonroad.com/documents/vilsacklettertogg.pdf   Save the Scenic Santa Ritas Fall Fundraiser, Thursday, November 12, 2009   Save the Scenic Santa Ritas is sponsoring a fundraising event on Thursday, November 12th at Old Town Artisans in Tucson.  For complete information on this event go to: http://www.scenicsantaritas.org/fallfundraiser.asp         11-7-2009

1/23/2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     Happy New Year!   Happy New Year to all MEAA supporters!  As announced in our last update from 2009 the public release date for the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) has been delayed until April, 2010.  When released we will need lots of help analyzing and commenting on the study.  Until then, we recommend that you keep up to date with all the activity related to the preparation of the DEIS.  Following are a few suggestions of websites or reports to consult.    Forest Service EIS Rosemont Copper Project Website    By consulting the Forest Service's EIS Rosemont Copper Project website (http://rosemonteis.us/) you can follow the deliberations of the cooperating agencies and view the many reports that are being considered in the preparation of the DEIS.  It's not easy to find the material, but if you're an expert in or especially interested in a particular topic plan to search the site on a regular basis.  For example, a search with the word "groundwater" retrieves the Eastside Mine Site Hydrogeology and Groundwater Modeling report.   Rosemont Copper Website   The Rosemont Copper website (http://www.rosemontcopper.com/index.html) provides access to reports prepared by Rosemont or its contractors.  Click on the Studies tab in the upper right.  The AZ 83 Roadway Assessment Report prepared for Rosemont by Tetra Tech is of particular interest and has been recently analyzed by Jim Kramp of the Hilton Road community and member of the MEAA steering committee.  A copy of his summary and analysis is available on the Hilton Road website ( http://www.hiltonroad.com/rosemontsr83.htm)   HR 2944 Hearings in Washington, DC   On January 21, 2010 the House of Representative's Committee on Natural Resources, Subcommittee on National Parks, Forests And Public Lands held hearings on HR 2944--the Southern Arizona Public Lands Protection Act of 2009.  The bill, sponsored by Congressman Raul Grijalva proposes to withdraw from mining federal lands located in Pima and Santa Cruz counties.  The full text of the bill can be found at: http://thomas.loc.gov  Enter the bill number 2944 in the search box in the middle of the page.   Testimony was provided by Dr. Ned Norris, Jr., Chairman, Tohono O'odham Nation; Chuck Huckelberry, Pima County Administrator; Nan Stockholm Walden, J.D., Vice President and Counsel, Farmers Investment Co. (FICO)/The Green Valley Pecan Company; Morris Farr, Vice President, Save the Scenic Santa Ritas; and Many Armenta, United Steelworkers of America.   A video of the hearing can be viewed at: http://resourcescommittee.house.gov/index.php?option=com_frontpage&Itemid=83  The testimony on HR2944 begins approximately 15 minutes into the video.   1-23-2010

3/3/2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     Plan to Attend the U.S. Forest Service Open House on Forest Service Plan Revisions, Tomorrow, March 4, 2010 from 4-7 p.m.   We have just learned that the Coronado National Forest is holding Forest Service Plan Revision Public Open Houses in March for Santa Catalina, Nogales, Sierra Vista, Douglas, and Safford Ranger Districts.   The NOGALES RANGER DISTRICT with its Santa Rita & Tumacacori Mountains will have its open house this Thursday, March 4 from 4:00 to 7:00 P.M. It will take place in Rio Rico at:   Esplendor Resort at Rio Rico Sonoran South Ballroom 1069 Camino Caralampi Rio Rico, AZ 85649   The presentation will be for one hour repeated each hour so people can come when most convenient. This is to review the initial "working draft" of the Revised Forest Plan for the Coronado National Forest Land and Resource Management Plan. The Forest Service will give an overview of the revised FS Plan which will provide "broad strategic guidance for the management of the Coronado National Forest for up to 15 years." Forest staff and resource specialists will be present to discuss the draft, receive ideas and input and respond to your questions.   We encourage your attendance to provide input about and to let the Forest Service know the public has interest. This is done every 15 years, and it is important that the Forest Service sees the public cares about being involved. The document includes direction of desired conditions, objectives, guidelines, standards, & suitable uses, and also has reports assessing areas for potential Wilderness designation.   For example, as shown in the map below the Forest Services proposes that the majority of the motorized recreation areas (in gray) in the entire Coronado National Forest be located in the Sonoita area:     For additional Plan information you can go to http://www.fs.fed.us/r3/coronado/plan-revision/ We also plan to request that the Forest Service schedule a meeting in the Sonoita/Patagonia area.   3-3-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     SAVE THE DATE for a meeting on the Coronado National Forest Plan Revision--Wednesday April 14, 6:30 p.m., Sonoita-Elgin Fire Station   The Forest Service has agreed to hold a meeting to review the proposed revision to the Coronado National Forest Plan in Sonoita.  Please save the date and plan to attend. Jennifer Ruyle will give an overview of the revised plan which will provide "broad strategic guidance for the management of the Coronado National Forest for up to 15 years." We expect that other staff and resource specialists will be present to discuss the draft, receive ideas and input and respond to your questions.   Of particular concern to Mountain Empire residents is the proposal that the majority of the Motorized Recreation areas (in gray on the map below) in the entire Coronado National Forest be located in the Sonoita area.  In the most recent Draft Forest Plan this area was designated as a Backcountry Recreation Land Use Zone. (see the following link) http://www.fs.fed.us/r3/coronado/plan-revision/graphics/maps/revisedplan/asritb.pdf .     To review the entire plan go to http://www.fs.fed.us/r3/coronado/plan-revision/   Letter Writing Campaign   You've no doubt noticed that Augusta Corporation has a very active publicity campaign about the benefits of the proposed Rosemont Mine.  To provide a balanced view of the issues, it is critical that our elected representatives, the press, and other citizens understand "the rest of the story."  There is an urgent need to write letters and/or Op Ed pieces on several pressing topics, including HB 2617 (see below).  MEAA will provide a list of points to cover in these letters to assist in the process. Please help; contact JoAnne Meyer at: rsannie@msn.   Arizona House Bill 2617   The Arizona House Bill HB 2617: mining amendments; water; permits; rules has passed the Natural Resources and Rural Affairs Committee.  This bill is of great concern because it weakens existing protections for Arizona water use, and decreases current restrictions on mining companies. Municipal water companies have intervened in the legislative process and are currently recommending significant changes to the bill.  All water users (including those on individual wells) should be alarmed at this proposed legislation. We'll keep you posted as to its status and request your assistance in contacting the state legislature now and in the future.  More information on the bill can be found at: www.azleg.gov.  Look for a follow-up message from MEAA with points to cover when writing to key legislators.   Help SSSR at Public Events   Save the Scenic Santa Ritas can use assistance at the following community events:   March 19-21 (Friday through Sunday, 10-6) - Spring 4th Ave Street Fair (Tucson) March 19-20 (Friday through Saturday, 9-4) - 46th Annual Spring Market (Green Valley Village Mall) March 27 (Saturday, 10-4) - 3rd Annual Santa Cruz County Energy Expo (Patagonia Union High School, Patagonia, AZ) April 17 (Saturday, 9-3) - 16th Annual Earth Day Festival in Reid Park (Reid Park, Tucson) April 24 (Saturday) - Patagonia Trails Day (Patagonia, AZ) May 1 (Saturday, 9-3) - 2nd Annual International Migratory Bird Day (Madera Canyon - White House Picnic Ramada)   If you are available to help on one of these days, please send an email to lisa@scenicsantaritas.org with the name of the event, day, and number of hours (in the morning or afternoon) you would like to help.   3-12-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News      Please Plan to Attend the Forest Plan Meeting In Sonoita   Wednesday April 14, 2010, Coronado National Forest Plan Revision, 6:30 p.m., Sonoita-Elgin Fire Station, 3173 Highway 83, Sonoita  The Forest Service will come to Sonoita to review the proposed revision to the Coronado National Forest Plan.  Please plan to attend. Jennifer Ruyle will give an overview of the revised plan which will provide "broad strategic guidance for the management of the Coronado National Forest for up to 15 years." We expect that other staff and resource specialists will be present to discuss the draft, receive ideas and input and respond to your questions.   Of particular concern to Mountain Empire residents is the proposal that the majority of the Motorized Recreation areas (in gray on the map below) in the entire Coronado National Forest be located in the Sonoita area.  In the most recent Draft Forest Plan this area was designated as a Backcountry Recreation Land Use Zone. (see the following link) http://www.fs.fed.us/r3/coronado/plan-revision/graphics/maps/revisedplan/asritb.pdf .     Tucson Electric Power (TEP) Public Information Open House   Tuesday, April 13, 2010,  5:30-8:30 p.m., Corona Foothills Middle School, 16705 South Houghton Road, Corona de Tucson   TEP has identified preliminary transmission line route alternatives for a 138kV transmission line to the proposed Rosemont Mine, should the mine be approved.  The public information open house will provide an opportunity to review and comment on the alternative routes.  You may attend any time between 5:30 and 8:30 p.m. A brief, formal presentation and question-and-answer session will be held from 6:30 to 7:00 p.m. each night. For more information, including maps of the proposed routes can be viewed at: http://www.tucsonelectric.com/Company/News/Rosemont/index.asp    Recent MEAA Education Efforts   This past week MEAA hosted two visits from key staff of Senators John Kyl and John McCain.  The purpose of the visits was to provide information on MEAA's concerns about the proposed Rosemont mine.  Presentations during the visit discussed issues of specific local concern, including adverse effect on Highway 83 travel, the local economy, ranching, outdoor recreation, tourism, real estate, property values, and flora and fauna. The meetings resulted in some very useful exchanges of information that we trust will be helpful to our Senators.   4-11-2010

 

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     New Delay Announced for Rosemont Copper Mine Project Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS)   The Coronado National Forest recently released the following announcement: "Due to the complexity of the proposed Rosemont Copper Project, the schedule for release of the Draft Environmental Impact Statement is being adjusted. Coronado National Forest personnel are currently involved in ongoing discussions with participants in the NEPA process to determine a schedule to facilitate a thorough evaluation of the proposal and other alternatives.   The additional time will allow the Forest to complete field surveys for a native plant (Hexa revoluta) that is found coincident with alternative project sites on National Forest land.  The time will also accommodate detailed groundwater hydrology studies which are being conducted on potential impacts and mitigation measures for alternatives under evaluation. The studies are expected to be completed during July. A revised schedule for the Draft Environmental Impact Statement will be announced within the next two months."   Comments on TEP's Alternative Routes to Provide Power to the Proposed Rosemont Mine due by May 7, 2010   Tucson Electric Power (TEP) is requesting comments on the proposed alternative routes to provide power to the proposed Rosemont Mine.  According to the TEP website, "If Rosemont secures approval for its proposed operations, a 138 kilovolt (kV) line would initially be built from an existing 46kV transmission line to the proposed Rosemont Substation to provide power for construction of the Rosemont operations facilities. Because that line is not adequate to provide power for Rosemont's long-term operations, a 138kV transmission line would be built, linking the Rosemont Substation to a proposed switchyard/substation tied to TEP's 138kV transmission system. Depending upon the final route selected, the route for the 138kV line could incorporate the transmission line and electrical facilities built to provide power for the construction of the Rosemont operations facilities."   A total of 10 alternative routes were initially considered.  At the Open Houses held by TEP in April the choices were narrowed to two alternative routes for the 138kV line and 3 routes for the 46kV construction lines.  Elizabeth Webb, a member of the stakeholders' group advising TEP during the planning process, recommends that TEP select a hybrid of Santa Rita Family Route 1 using links 20, 25, 60, 100, 105, 155, 140, EXCLUDING links 185, 170, 160, 190, and 210. This alternative would result in only one line for both construction and permanent power and would eliminate construction through the Coronado National Forest south of the proposed Rosemont Mine site.  She also recommends that TEP place links 20, 25, 60, and 100 underground and explore the feasibility of placing the remaining links underground as well.  Ms. Webb recommends this alternative because the route is adjacent to an existing transportation corridor and the proposed water line route for the mine; placing lines underground would mitigate the visual contrast created by new vertical transmission structures along Santa Rita Rd.; and there would be no new disturbance in the CNF or potential to increase rate base for the ratepayers in the future.   We encourage MEAA members to study the TEP alternatives and submit comments to TEP by May 7th using the public comment form on the TEP website.   MEAA Meetings with Arizona Public Media (KUAT) and ADOT   As part of our ongoing educational efforts concerning the negative effects of the proposed Rosemont Copper mine MEAA members held meetings with staff from Arizona Public Media (KUAT) and Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT).  At the KUAT meeting we urged KUAT to evaluate the coverage they are giving to the Rosemont Mine story and that they provide more investigative and in depth coverage of the important issues related to the proposed mine in areas such as water, environmental effect, and economic impact.  The meeting with ADOT focused on ADOT's role as a cooperating agency with the Forest Service to evaluate the potential impact of the proposed mine, especially the adverse effects on Highway 83 and those who travel that route.   Forest Service Plan Comments   The MEAA comments on the Coronado National Forest (CNF) Working Draft Land and Resource Management Plan were submitted on April 30, 2010.   An article about the Sonoita meeting with CNF staff was published in the April 28, 2010 issue of The Bulletin.   5-4-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News    Your Letters or Emails to the Bureau of Reclamation Needed by May 21, 2010   Just over a year ago we asked for your help in commenting on the Bureau of Reclamation's (BOR) Draft Environmental Assessment (DEA) for the Community Water Company of Green Valley's (CWC) Proposed Central Arizona Project (CAP) Water Distribution System and Recharge Facility.  The BOR recently released a revised DEA for public review and comment, and we strongly encourage you to write again to express your concern about the proposed project.  Following is a sample letter that we hope will be of assistance.    Ms. Sandra Eto U. S. Department of Interior Bureau of Reclamation Phoenix Area Office, 6150 West Thunderbird Road Glendale AZ 85306   Attention: PXAO-1500 (Ms. Sandra Eto)   Re:  NEPA Comments on the Draft Environmental Assessment for the proposed Community Water Company of Green Valley Central Arizona Project Water Distribution System and Recharge Facility, Pima County, Arizona   Dear Ms. Eto:   This letter sets forth comments on the Draft Environmental Assessment ("DEA") for the construction and operation of the proposed Community Water Company ("CWC") of Green Valley Central Arizona Project Water Distribution System and Recharge Facility in Pima County, Arizona ("Proposed Project"), prepared for the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation ("Reclamation")  It will be shown below that CWC and Augusta Resource Corporation ("ARC"), in their very own words, have themselves made the case that the Proposed Project and ARC's Proposed Rosemont Copper Project are in fact connected actions. This case is presented in four parts:  (1) excerpts from relevant documents in the public record, (2) summary of facts derived from the excerpts, (3) conclusions supported by the facts, and (4) recommendations.   1.  EXCERPTS FROM RELEVANT DOCUMENTS IN THE PUBLIC RECORD From ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation dated July 11, 2007, Section 2.8.5 Recharge Plan: "Rosemont has made a commitment to the local community to utilize available CAP water to recharge 105% of the total water production over the life of the Project.  The recharge will be within the Tucson AMA, and as close to the water production site as possible.  The total life-of-the-mine usage is currently estimated to be 100,000 af, resulting in a recharge commitment of 105,000 af." "Pima Mine Road is the state-permitted underground storage facility closest to [water production] Site 1. Because available capacity at this facility may remain limited for the foreseeable future, Rosemont Copper has also begun evaluating construction of a new recharge facility in close proximity to it." From the Letter of Intent between ARC and CWC dated July 12, 2007, p. 1: "Augusta Resource Corporation (ARC) plans to procure and recharge CAP water in the vicinity of its Rosemont Mine well site, a 53 acre parcel of land located on Davis Road, Sahuarita, AZ (ARC 53 Acre Parcel).  The availability of a suitable pipeline and recharge facility is critical to the eventual implementation of this plan." From the Letter of Intent between ARC and CWC dated July 12, 2007, p. 2: "The parties have established a CAP Water Delivery System (WDS) Plan as presented in a briefing dated June 18, 2007, and that Plan is incorporated as Appendix A to this Letter of Intent." From the Letter of Intent between ARC and CWC dated July 12, 2007, p. 3: "ARC and CWCGV will form a WDS Project Team comprised of two members each and an alternate from each.  The WDS Project Team will report directly to the appropriate management of ARC and CWCGV.  The WDS Project Team will have specific construction milestone and operation milestone responsibilities." From Appendix A to the Letter of Intent between ARC and CWC dated July 12, 2007, p. 12 (text on Diagram): "Other Development Partners could be brought in through the Main Line Extension Agreement prior to construction start." From Appendix A to the Letter of Intent between ARC and CWC dated July 12, 2007, p. 13: "Additional Partner(s) to contract for water transport and recharge, and share in the construction cost of an enlarged system, are sought by the WDS Project Team." From the letter to Pima County Supervisor Ray Carroll from CWC Chairman of the Board Ken Taylor dated August 22, 2007: "In the two years Community Water Company and, independently, a group of concerned citizens of Green Valley, have been actively pursuing funding for this project, we have not been successful in locating these readily available alternative funding sources." "Since we have not yet signed a binding agreement with Augusta Resources Corporation, we will be happy to discuss any firm commitment to a similar transaction with any entity that has funds readily available for our project." From Reclamation's Draft Environmental Assessment, Section 1.5 Relationship to Proposed Rosemont Mine: "Reclamation recognizes that construction of the Proposed Project is proposed to be funded by Rosemont and that CWC plans to give priority for use of CWC's CAP water and available recharge storage capacity for the first 15 to 20 years of the systems operation unless needed by CWC.  However, as discussed further in the Scoping Report in Appendix B and below, Reclamation has determined that the Proposed Project and the proposed Rosemont Mine are not connected actions under NEPA." "Presently, use of the CWC water delivery system is not identified in Rosemont's mine plan of operation (MPO) under consideration by the Coronado National Forest." From Reclamation's Draft Environmental Assessment, Section 2.3 Proposed Action: "CWC has agreed to give Rosemont priority for use of CWC's 2,858 AFY of CAP water for the first 15 to 20 years of the system's operation unless it is needed by CWC. Under the Preferred Alternative, this water would be recharged at the proposed recharge site, along with additional water supplies Rosemont may obtain to utilize the maximum recharge capacity of 5,000 AFY at the site." From Reclamation's Draft Environmental Assessment, Project Financing,p.16: "The Agreement between CWC and Rosemont has not been finalized, and thus Reclamation and CAWCD have not been able to review any portion of the Agreement."  2.  SUMMARY OF FACTS DERIVED FROM THE EXCERPTS ARC and CWC jointlycompleted a plan for construction of a CAP Water Delivery System and Recharge Facility on June 18, 2007, which was incorporated into the Letter of Intent between them and which is the Proposed Project currently under review by the Reclamation. ARC and CWC are "Development Partners." The Proposed Project is managed by the WDS Project Team consisting of members of both ARC and CWC reporting to and acting under the direction of their respective companies. ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation was dated and submitted to the Coronado National Forest ("CNF") July 11, 2007. The ARC/CWC plan for constructing a CAP water delivery pipeline and recharge facility was completed a month prior to ARC's completion and submission of its Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation to the CNF. The ARC/CWC plan could easily have been incorporated by name into ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation's recharge plan, but as a conscious decision by ARC it was not. Reclamation's determination that ARC's Proposed Rosemont Mine and the Proposed Project are not connected actions under NEPA was based in part on the observation that ARC's use of the Proposed Project's water delivery system is not specifically identified by name in ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation. The availability of a suitable CAP water delivery pipeline and recharge facility is critical to the implementation of the recharge plan in ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation. The maximum capacity of the Proposed Project's recharge facility is 5,000 acre-feet per year-exactly equal to ARC's annual recharge commitment. Without Reclamation's approval of the Proposed Project, ARC's CAP water contract with the Pima Mine Road Recharge Facility will not be sufficient to meet ARC's commitment to recharge 105,000 acre-feet of water over the lifetime of the proposed Rosemont Mine. The final "Agreement Relating to Extension of Water Distribution Facilities" that would provide ARC funding for the Proposed Project has not been executed by ARC and CWC to date, nor has a binding agreement for project funding been executed by CWC and any other entity to date. Funding for the Proposed Project, therefore, remains uncertain.  3.  CONCLUSIONS SUPPORTED BY THE FACTS ARC knowingly and inappropriately withheld full disclosure in its Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation that its Recharge Plan and the Proposed Project are in fact one and the same; and it did so intentionally to avoid the unwanted consequences of a correct determination by the CNF and Reclamation that ARC's proposed Rosemont Mine and the Proposed Project are connected actions under NEPA.  ARC and CWC, through the WDS Project Team, are Development Partners in the Proposed Project.  ARC is not simply an independent funding entity but a central participant in the design, construction, management and operation of the proposed facility. Thus, ARC's proposed Rosemont Mine is directly connected and integral to the Proposed Project. That the maximum capacity of the Proposed Project's recharge facility is 5,000 acre-feet per year-exactly equal to ARC's annual recharge commitment-cannot be a coincidence.  The availability to ARC of a suitable pipeline and recharge facility is critical to the implementation of its Recharge Plan.  Without approval of the Proposed Project, ARC will not be able to implement the CAP Recharge Plan in its Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation.  Absent a viable recharge plan, CNF's approval of ARC's Rosemont Mine Plan of Operation is unlikely.  Therefore, approval of ARC's proposed Rosemont Mine is in fact dependent upon Reclamation's approval of the Proposed Project. Neither ARC nor any other entities to date have entered into a binding  agreement with CWC to fund the Proposed Project.  Absent a binding final agreement between ARC and CWC that guarantees funds for project design and construction costs, funding for the Proposed Project is uncertain and Reclamation's approval of the Proposed Project is unlikely.  Therefore, approval of the Proposed Project is in fact dependent upon approval of ARC's proposed Rosemont Mine. 4.  RECOMMENDATIONS   ARC's and CWC's own words and actions make the case that ARC's Proposed Rosemont Mine and the CAP Water Delivery System and Recharge Facility proposed by CWC are in fact connected actions.  Therefore, the Bureau of Reclamation must (a) reverse its decision to the contrary, (b) communicate its decision to the Coronado National Forest that ARC's Proposed Rosemont Mine and the Proposed Project are connected actions under NEPA, (c) jointly with the Coronado National Forest, expand/convert the pending environmental assessment to a full, combined environmental impact statement for both ARC's Proposed Rosemont Copper Project and the Proposed Project, and (d) upon completion of the above, expand the scoping period to permit a full review and comment by the public, particularly in Green Valley and Sahuarita.   Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this important public matter.    5-13-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     You've Asked if You Can Help Financially-Now is the time!   Many of you have asked members of the MEAA Steering Committee if you can help financially in MEAA's fight to stop the proposed Rosemont Mine.  To date, our efforts have required primarily "sweat equity"-hundreds of volunteer hours devoted to research, writing, educating and communicating.  We now have a project for which we need your financial support.  MEAA has engaged Thomas Michael Power, a Professor Emeritus at the University of Montana who has spent the past two decades addressing the very economic issues we are facing with the proposed Rosemont Mine, to prepare a series of reports designed to document the potential economic costs and adverse impacts to our community.   The reports will be submitted to the Coronado National Forest to be formally considered in the preparation of the draft environmental impact report.   Over the next several months Dr. Power will: Update the 2007 Marlow-Sonoran Institute Study commissioned by Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, and expand it to include an amenity-supported economic development approach. Prepare a comparative analysis of the competitive position of the Tucson area in attracting businesses and workers. Document the adverse economic impacts on the complex of conservation lands surrounding the proposed Rosemont Mine. Critique the  Rosemont Mine assertions about how the mine would boost tourism.  Prepare a critique of the Rosemont sponsored economic studies including the November 2009 study prepared by an Arizona State University economist/business school faculty and a Scottsdale Real Estate Developer. Visit Tucson to discuss the results of his work with Coronado National Forest staff, government, civic and business leaders, the media, and the community. Our current fundraising goal is $25,000 for the Power study and other follow-on efforts. Please help now!    Because MEAA does not have a 501c3 status, we are delighted that Save the Scenic Santa Ritas has agreed to serve as our fiscal agent so that all donations will be tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law.  Make your check payable to Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, with a notation on the memo line of the check that it is for MEAA.  Mail the check to:   Mountain Empire Action Alliance P. O. Box 14 Sonoita, AZ 85637   We are most grateful for the generosity of those who have already contributed to this important effort!   Please join your friends and neighbors with your support.  Your help is critical to the fight against the Rosemont Mine and other planned mines in the Mountain Empire.   5-20-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News      Thanks for Donating!   We are so grateful to those of you who responded to our request for financial assistance to fund the work of Thomas Michael Power, Research Professor and Professor Emeritus, Department of Economics, University of Montana to prepare a series of reports designed to document the potential economic costs and adverse impacts of the proposed Rosemont Mine to our community.  We have made great progress toward our fundraising goal of $25,000, but still need your help.  Due to our affiliation with Save the Scenic Santa Ritas your donation will be fully tax deductible.  Make your check payable to Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, with a notation on the memo line of the check that it is for MEAA.  Mail the check to:   Mountain Empire Action Alliance P. O. Box 14 Sonoita, AZ 85637   Save Wednesday, June 30th, 7-8:30 p.m. for a Presentation by Dr. Thomas Michael Power   As part of his agreement with MEAA, Dr. Power will spend 3 days in the Mountain Empire and Tucson to discuss the results of his work with Coronado National Forest staff, civic and business leaders, the media, and the community.  On Wednesday, June 30th he will make a presentation in Sonoita (location to be announced) from 7-8:30 p.m.  The presentation will summarize his economic analyses, focusing on impacts on local businesses and residents, and will be followed by a question and answer session.  Please plan to attend!   Wine Country NOT Mine Country   Be among the first to wear the new MEAA t-shirts!  Available in men's (tan) and women's (blue) sizes.  A $20 donation is all it takes.  MEAA will have the t-shirts at Callaghan's Vineyards on Saturday, June 19th (during the Wine, Dine & Unwind event) or they can be obtained from JoAnne Meyer rsannie@msn.com                     6-9-10

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News       EYE-OPENING TALKS YOU DON'T WANT TO MISS ON THE ECONOMIC THREATS OF THE PROPOSED ROSEMONT MINE!    Wednesday, June 30th, at 7:00 p.m. Pioneer Hall, Sonoita Fairgrounds, 3142 S. Hwy. 83, Sonoita                                             -or- Thursday, July 1st, at 10:30 a.m. Viscount Suite Hotel, Salon B, 4855 E. Broadway Blvd., Tucson    AUGUSTA RESOURCE CORPORATION AND ROSEMONT COPPER COMPANY ARE NOT TELLING THE PUBLIC THE WHOLE ECONOMIC TRUTH ABOUT THE OPEN PIT COPPER MINE THEY PROPOSE TO CONSTRUCT IN THE SANTA RITA MOUNTAINS OF THE CORONADO NATIONAL FOREST, TEN MILES FROM SONOITA.    Dr. Thomas Power, Research Professor and Professor Emeritus, Department of Economics, University of Montana, will be in Sonoita and Tucson to discuss the very real threats that the proposed Rosemont Mine would pose to our local businesses, regional economy, and quality of life.  Dr. Power is a nationally recognized expert on the economic impacts of industrial exploitation of natural resources on surrounding communities, and is the author of "LOST LANDSCAPES AND FAILED ECONOMIES:  THE SEARCH FOR A VALUE OF PLACE."  In his book, Dr. Power makes a persuasive case that preservation of the natural landscape can be more valuable to the local community's long-term economic development and health than the short-lived value of extracting and processing local natural resources.   For almost 40 years, Dr. Power has been applying the analytical tools of Natural Resource Economics and Regional Economics to public policy issues, focusing on how extractive industries such as mining are intertwined with and adversely impacting environmental factors central to local economic vitality and well being. During his career, Dr. Power has assisted over 50 local and state governments, non-governmental organizations, and Tribal governments.   The Mountain Empire Action Alliance, which has commissioned Dr. Power to conduct an independent, objective study of the economic impacts of the proposed Rosemont Mine, invites you to attend and join the presentation and discussion at either the Sonoita Fairgrounds in Sonoita, or the Viscount Suite Hotel in Tucson.   We encourage you to share this invitation with your friends and neighbors.   6-17-10

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News       Please Plan to Attend one of two Talks on the Economic Threats of the Proposed Rosemont Mine!    Wednesday, June 30th, at 7:00 p.m. Pioneer Hall, Sonoita Fairgrounds, 3142 S. Hwy. 83, Sonoita                                                 -or- Thursday, July 1st, at 10:30 a.m. Viscount Suite Hotel, Salon B, 4855 E. Broadway Blvd., Tucson    Dr. Thomas Power, Research Professor and Professor Emeritus, Department of Economics, University of Montana, will be in Sonoita and Tucson to discuss the very real threats that the proposed Rosemont Mine would pose to our local businesses, regional economy, and quality of life.     Come early to the Sonoita meeting to get your MEAA Wine Country NOT Mine Country t-shirts!   Let  KIIM FM Know How you Feel about Rosemont Copper's Sponsorship of the Freedom Fest on July 3rd.    KIIM-FM has accepted sponsorship funding from Rosemont copper for its Freedom Fest on July 3rd.  We encourage you to contac KIIM-FM to let them know why you won't be attending the concert.  Following is some suggested wording:    I'm sorry to report that my friends and I won't be the Freedom Concert because it is sponsored by the Rosemont Copper Company.  Rosemont, a Canadian company, wants to mine throughout the Santa Rita and Patagonia Mountains South of Tucson starting with a huge open pit mine that would require depositing over 3,600 acres of waste rock and mine tailings on public land situated in one of the most scenic and ecologically important mountain areas in Southern Arizona.  The proposed project is located 12 miles from the City of Tucson and within a watershed serving the City's water supply.  It is no surprise that the proposal has generated widespread opposition from the public and from virtually all local governments in the area.  To learn more visit: http://www.hiltonroad.com/rosemont.htm   Comments should be sent to: http://www.kiimfm.com/contactus.asp   Can you help at the Patagonia 4th of July Parade?   MEAA will have a booth at the Patagonia 4th of July festival, and will be promoting our Wine Country NOT Mine Country t-shirts.  We'll also participate in the parade, wearing our t-shirts.  If you'd like to help and/or walk in the parade, contact Renee Roberts Renrb7@aol.com   SSSR is also in need of a few volunteersto help with their booth.  If you are available and would like to help out with this event, please contact Lisa Froelich with your availability lisa@scenicsantaritas.org   6-25-10

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News       Tom Power's Visit to the Mountain Empire and Tucson   Thanks to everyone who took advantage of the various opportunities to hear Dr. Tom Power's presentations on his preliminary analysis of the potential economic costs and adverse impacts to our community from the proposed Rosemont Mine.  Dr. Power's three day visit began with a tour of the Rosemont Valley followed by a donor reception and dinner in Sonoita.  On Wednesday, June 30th he met with U.S. Forest Service staff and representatives of the cooperating agencies involved in the preparation of the draft Environmental Impact Study (EIS); with reporters from the Arizona Daily Star, Green Valley News and Sun, and Nogales International; and representatives from the hospitality and tourism industry.  His Wednesday evening presentation in Sonoita was attended by almost 100 interested individuals.  On Thursday approximately 135 attended his presentation in Tucson, which was followed by a lunch with local policy makers.    If you were unable to attend the talks, there are a variety of ways you can learn more about Dr. Power's presentation.  Bob Harris, of the Hilton Ranch Road Community, has prepared an excellent video of the Sonoita presentation.  A copy of the video is available for viewing at the Sonoita Library.  Following are some links to news articles about the presentation that provide additional insight.   Economist: Rosemont not worth the high price by Philip Franchine, Green Valley News and Sun, Friday, July 2, 2010 406 jobs won't help, says Rosemont critic by Tony Davis. Arizona Daily Star, Sunday, July 4, 2010   Stay tuned for information on how to obtain a copy of the final report when it is completed at the end of the month.   News of Note   We recommend the following letters and commentaries which have recently been published:   Before it's too late, let's address Rosemont Mine's worst-case scenarios by Sarah Barchas, Arizona Daily Star, Friday, July 2, 2010   Chamber acted too hastily in endorsing mine Arizona Daily Star, Monday, June 28, 2010   UA Scientists Study Contaminants in Arizona Air, Water by Ginny Geib, UA News    MEAA in Patagonia on the 4th of July     MEAA t-shirts are still available for a $20 donation.  Contact JoAnne Meyer rsannie@msn.com to reserve yours.   7-9-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News       Panoramic Photos of the East Side of the Santa Rita Mountains Available   Patagonia professional photographer, Glenn "Gooch" Goodwin has donated to MEAA a beautiful panoramic photo (see above) of a view across the Rosemont Valley from the east side of the Santa Rita Mountains.  Jones Photo in Tucson will print the photos at a quantity discount, provided MEAA submits a minimum of 10 orders. We are pleased to offer two sizes and styles of the photo as a fundraiser for MEAA's fight against the proposed Rosemont Mine.    Description  Suggested Donation 8"x40" print only  $40 8"x40" print with mounting on 3/16" gator board  $70 16"x80" print only  $100 16"x80" print with mounting on 3/16" gator board  $180   Each photo will be signed by the photographer.  If you are interested in obtaining a photo, please contact Joan Williams joansonoita@aol.com.  A 50% deposit is required for all orders.   News of Note   We recommend the following articles which have recently been published:      Economist says Rosemont Mine not a wise choice for local residents by JB Miller for The Bulletin UA Finds Tailing Have Troubling Tiny Particles by Tony Davis for the Arizona Daily Star Protection sought for 2 plants spotted near Rosemont site by Tony Davis for the Arizona Daily Star Rosemont goes ahead in buying equipment for mine by Tony Davis for the Arizona Daily Star   The last article on this list is especially pertinent for those who witnessed the wide load transport of some Rosemont equipment a few weeks ago and are concerned that the mine is proceeding.  As a reminder, the mine has not been approved; the draft environmental impact report is not expected before the end of 2010.   MEAA T-Shirts Still Available   The MEAA "Wine Country NOT Mine Country" t-shirts are still available for a $20 donation.  T-shirts can be obtained at the Sonoita Inn or Sonoita Mercantile, and will be available at the  Arts and Crafts Fair, Elgin Community Club, July 31-August 1st between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m.       7-20-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News       Plan to Attend a Meeting with Republican Candidate Jonathan Paton, Tuesday, August 3, 6:00 p.m., 537 First Avenue, Patagonia   Jonathan Paton, Republican candidate for Congressional District 8, is coming to the Mountain Empire to meet with all who are concerned about the impact of the proposed Rosemont mine.  Paton is  the only GOP candidate of the three running for this office who is on the record as opposing the Rosemont mine.    Mr. Paton is interested in learning about our local concerns, and will stress his opposition to the proposed Rosemont mine.  Members of Save the Scenic Santa Ritas (SSSR), the Mountain Empire Action Alliance (MEAA), and others interested are encouraged to attend to present information and various perspectives regarding the negative impact that the proposed mine will have if it is approved.    This informative gathering will be Tuesday, August 3rd, at 6:00 p.m. Deborah Fain has been kind enough to offer her home in Patagonia for the meeting.  Following are her phone numbers and directions to her house:   Telephone numbers:  home:  520-394-2161, cell:  520-404-1599; office:  520-455-5983.   Directions: From Hwy 82 coming South from Sonoita, turn right on First Ave. immediately after passing  the high school.  From Hwy 82 coming North from Nogales, turn left on First Ave. immediately before the high school. Travel approximately 1/3 of a mile on First Avenue passing Three R Ave. on the right and North St. on the right. Almost immediately after passing North St. you will see a white mailbox on your left with the address 537.  Immediately after the mailbox is a dirt road.  Turn left onto the dirt road. Go through the dry wash (Gringo Wash).  As you exit the wash on the other side you can bear left or right of the fence. Bear left and go through the gate.  Follow the road around the barn and up the hill on your left. The house is on the hill, painted the color of Merlot with a gray tin roof.  Park anywhere.   Please forward this e-mail invitation to as many as possible who may want to attend.   PLEASE RSVP to: BernitaBarfield@aol.com or call for more information: 520-455-5953 (home) or 530-490-5996 (cell)       7-30-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News      Internal Review Version of Chapter 1 of the Draft Environmental Impact Study (DEIS) Released by the Forest Service to Cooperating Agencies    At the July 15, 2010 meeting of Cooperating Agencies, which are assisting in the analysis  of the proposed Rosemont Mine project, the Coronado National Forest (CNF) distributed two documents of interest.  The documents have also been posted to the CNF Rosemont Copper Project website. Internal Review Version DEIS Chapter 1 Cover Letter for DEIS Chapter 1 Review The Internal Review Version of Chapter 1 provides a "sneak preview" of what the DEIS will look like, including its contents.  When reading the draft chapter, it is important to keep in mind that the term "Proposed Action" used in this chapter refers to the action proposed by the proponent of the mine, namely Augusta/Rosemont Copper.  It is not CNF's "Proposed Action."  The CNF is saying in these draft documents that it must consider the "Proposed Action" along with a number of "Alternative Actions" including the "No Action Alternative."  These draft documents do not yet hint at any preliminary decision by the CNF.   Economic Threats of the Proposed Rosemont Mine Presentation Now on You Tube!   The June 30, 2010 presentation by Dr. Thomas Power, Research Professor and Professor Emeritus, Department of Economics, University of Montana is now on YouTube.  Just click on the links below.   Part 1 (Introduction)  http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/6/D9kPQmrz8Nw Part 2 (Recession) http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/5/6doaFnI9SK0 Part 3 (Tucson Economic Growth) http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/4/6tCLuk_IEgo Part 4 (Non-Employment Income) http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/3/SQVrg8tSiiE Part 5 (Multipliers) http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/2/mrvkVlrg8UY Part 6 ("Angelic Mine") http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/1/NGhrlOve7Ds Part 7 (It's Your Land!) http://www.youtube.com/user/azroberth#p/u/0/FZe0ym_AW8M    Air Quality Permit Application   The Air Quality Permit Application and accompanying documents submitted by Augusta Mining Corporation to the Pima County Department of Evironmental Quality can be viewed at: http://www.deq.pima.gov/permits/RosemontCopper.htm   8-7-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     MEAA Fact Sheets   MEAA has prepared a series of fact sheets detailing our viewpoints about the proposed Rosemont Mine.  We hope these will prove useful when discussing the proposed mine with others.  Following is the text of the first fact sheet; a pdf version that can be printed for sharing is available at:  http://www.hiltonroad.com/documents/Top%20Ten%20Reasons.pdf   Top Ten Reasons Why the Mountain Empire Action Alliance Is Opposed to the Proposed Rosemont Mine  Water, Arizona's most valuable natural resource, will be endangered-- The Mine has an expected demand of 5,000 acre-feet of water per year or 100,000 acre-feet of water over the lifetime of the Mine.  Despite an already stressed ground water supply and significant anticipated population growth in Pima and Santa Cruz counties, Augusta will have no legally enforceable obligation to replace the ground water that it uses. Arizona doesn't need another copper mine, especially one with no infrastructure in place-Arizona's mine are operating at only 50% capacity and already have needed infrastructure. Augusta Resource Corporation has never operated a mine-How much trust can we place in their claims that the "state of the art" methods they are proposing will not result in environmental and public health hazards? The copper deposit is low grade, requiring enormous excavation in order to recover the minerals--Up to 1.9-billion tons of waste rock will be produced to obtain 600-million tons of copper-bearing ore over the Mine's lifetime.  Most of the mine's copper & profits will be leaving the state and the country. The mine pit will be huge and the area of the tailing and leach pits will be 18,000 feet long.  The pit will be 6,500 feet long, 6,000 feet wide, and up to 3,000 feet deep.  The tailings will extend a length equivalent to 9 Washington Monument reflecting pools laid end to end. A total of 4,415 acres of already vanishing outdoor space for human recreation and wildlife habitat for rare and endangered species of plants and animals will be destroyed--995 acres will be on private land; 3,345 acres will be on federal lands managed by the Coronado National Forest and the Bureau of Land Management; and 75 acres will be on state trust lands. Arizona Scenic Highway 83 will no longer be scenic or safe--On average, there will be 150 vehicles arriving at the Mine and 150 vehicles departing the Mine per day, the majority of which will be heavy trucks, many transporting toxic material. The economies of Tucson, Elgin, Sonoita, Patagonia, and surrounding areas will suffer--The scenic natural landscapes that annually attract millions of visitors, thousands of new residents and highly skilled workers, and hundreds of new businesses and industries to Pima and Santa Cruz Counties are far more important to the region's economic development and health than the 406 jobs the proposed Mine plans to create. Blasting and digging will pollute our environment--Blasting will be done by exploding 20,000 tons of ammonium nitrate per year or 380-thousand tons; digging and hauling will be done by heavy machinery burning and converting to tail-pipe emissions 9-million gallons of diesel fuel per year or 171-million gallons over the Mine's estimated lifetime. Large open pit copper mines can and do fail, leaving the immense burdens of mine closure, habitat reclamation, and remediation of environmental contamination to the tax payers.  In the last 20 years, at least 15 "state-of-the-art" mines have filed for protection under bankruptcy leaving to the taxpayers the immense financial burden of mine closure, remediation of environmental contamination, and habitat reclamation totaling over $12-billion. Article of Interest   Review for mine could be delayed by Tony Davis, Arizona Daily Star     8-12-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Visibility Analysis of the Proposed Rosemont Copper Project   The "Coalition to Stop Mining the Santa Ritas", which consists of MEAA, Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, the Center for Biological Diversity, the Arizona Mining Reform Coalition, and Sky Island Alliance submitted on July 24, 2010 a scoping comment that consists of a visibility analysis of the proposed Rosemont Copper Project.  The analysis clearly demonstrates that the development of the Rosemont mine will significantly impact the viewsheds of southern Arizona, and that the impacts are significantly expanded in the event the Augusta Corporation and the Rosemont Copper Company proceed with development of their additional claim holdings in the Santa Ritas including the Broad Top area.   The documentation includes four visibility maps which illustrate the regions from which the proposed and planned mines would be visible including the following public lands and cities:    Public lands ·         Saguaro National Park; ·         Vast portions of Coronado National Forest (including at least eight mountain ranges: ·         Rincon, Empire, Whetstone, Huachuca, Canelo Hills, Patagonia, Catalina, and Santa ·         Rita (including the Mount Wrightson Wilderness Area); ·         Vast portions of the Las Cienegas National Conservation Area (BLM); ·         Tohono O'odham Nation - San Xavier District ·         Pascua Yaqui Tribal Lands ·         Scenic State Highway 83 ·         Santa Rita Experimental Range and Wildlife Area; ·         Pima County Conservation Lands; ·         Cienega Creek Natural Reserve; and ·         Vast portions of Arizona State Trust Lands (including the Mustang Mountains). Cities ·         Tucson (metropolitan area) ·         Green Valley ·         Marana ·         Oro Valley ·         Sahuarita ·         Vail ·         Corona de Tucson ·         Sonoita ·         Elgin ·         Amado ·         Continental ·         Sierra Vista   The scoping comments letter makes the point that although views from many of these areas would be classified as "background views", the immense size of the proposed mine/waste-rock/tailings complex (over 2.67 miles in width and nearly 4 miles in length), in combination with the color and form contrasts of these proposed and planned mining operations, along with the inevitable dust blowing off the complex, would result in an overall degradation of visual and scenic quality, producing a net decrease in the overall amenity value of the region; a value of critical importance in maintaining the quality of life of the residents as well as attractiveness for visitors.  We encourage you to take a look at the visibility maps; be patient with the download of the pdf documents it is a very large file (33.67 MB)   Article of Interest   Analysis warns mine will obstruct views by Philip Franchine, Green Valley News   8-16-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Report on the Economic Impacts of the Proposed Rosemont Copper Project Released   In November 2009, Augusta Resource Corporation/Rosemont Copper Company (Rosemont) released a widely publicized study - An Assessment of the Economic Impacts of the Rosemont Copper Project on the Economies of the Cochise/Pima/Santa Cruz Counties Study Area, Arizona, and the United States.  In February 2010 Rosemont hosted a forum on the economic impacts of the proposed mine.  Both the report and the forum discussed only the possible short-term benefits of the proposed project.  Wholly absent is any analysis of adverse impacts, including the possible long-term public costs and risks to the regional economy that may derive from the construction and operation of the proposed mine on National Forest and other public lands.  In terms of a public policy perspective, the study commissioned by the proponent of the project is biased and incomplete.   Absent a balanced and comprehensive analysis of the economic effects of the proposed Rosemont Mine, the Mountain Empire Action Alliance commissioned Dr. Thomas M. Power to analyze both the possible public economic benefits of the proposed project and its possible public costs and economic risks to the regional and local economies.  Dr. Power is Research Professor and Professor Emeritus, Department of Economics, University of Montana, and Consulting Economist, Power Consulting. Dr. Power was also asked to review and critique the Assessment of Economic Impacts prepared for Rosemont, to provide an economic context for evaluating the proposed project in terms of both the Tucson regional economy and the economics of the copper mining industry, and to discuss the broader non-market economic costs resulting from likely adverse impacts of the proposed project.    Dr. Power's analysis of the proposed project's economic impacts on Tucson and surrounding Pima and Santa Cruz Counties raises serious concerns that are not addressed in the study commissioned by Rosemont.  Uppermost among them is that mining is no longer a corner stone of the region's economic base.  Of the approximately 520,500 jobs in Pima County, the mining industry accounts for less than one percent of the total and is declining.  Dr. Power finds that the economic health and continuing development of this region is far more reliant upon its other and more abundant natural resources:  sunshine, exceptionally attractive natural surroundings, and superior outdoor recreational opportunities.   These irreplaceable natural resources are vital attractors of the region's millions of annual visitors, thousands of resident skilled workers, hundreds of new businesses and industries, and the billions of dollars they generate for the regional economy.  These natural attractors are the key drivers of the region's future and sustainable economic growth.  As a comparative measure of job-creating power, there are 22,770 existing direct jobs associated with the Pima County travel industry alone-almost 60 times as many jobs as those projected by the proposed Rosemont Mine.  Rather than being a long-term benefit to the regional economy, the results of mining public lands in Pima and Santa Cruz Counties are the long-term exclusion of public access and enjoyment, and the eventual destruction of the very public lands that are the drivers of the region's future and sustainable economic growth.  Dr. Power finds that even if the proposed project has just a very slight impact on the travel industry in the region, the travel job losses could be much greater than the mining job gains.   For the Coronado National Forest, the decision-making calculus regarding the pending application of the proposed project cannot be guided solely by the possible limited and short-term mining job gains and the alleged economic benefits as set forth in the Rosemont study.  There must also be a thorough analysis of the possible long-term public costs and risks to the realization of a sustainable regional economy that the proposed Rosemont Mine would pose.   Dr. Power's report contains five separate scoping comment papers:   I.  Thinking Analytically about the Local Economy and Local Economic Well Being: The Limits of the "Cattle, Cotton, and Copper" View of the Arizona Economy II. The Economic Context in Which to Evaluate the Proposed Rosemont Mine III. The Promises and Reality of Copper Mining IV. Rosemont Copper's Projections of Economic Impacts V.  Economic Values Put at Risk by the Proposed Rosemont Mine   The Mountain Empire Action Alliance also prepared a set of appendices as background material for Dr. Powers; these appendices are:   Appendix A: Public Land Investments Appendix B: Greater Tucson Region - Study Area Data Table B-1: Public Land Areas Table B-2: Public Land Values Appendix C-1: Summary of Likely Significant Adverse Impacts on Non-Market Values Appendix C-2: Illustrative Examples of Non-Market Values   The report has been distributed by MEAA to over 40 public officials, political candidates, media, and business leaders.  The report plus appendices can be viewed at:   Hilton Ranch Road Community website:http://www.hiltonroad.com/rosemonteconomic.htm Save the Scenic Santa Ritas website: http://www.scenicsantaritas.org/2010_economic_study.asp   Print copies of the report will be made available at the Sonoita and Patagonia libraries.   MEAA is most grateful for the donations received that made it possible to commission Dr. Power's analysis, his visit to Southeastern Arizona, and the distribution of the report.   Article and reports of Interest   The Economic Benefits of Southern New Mexico's Natural Assets by Headwaters Economics Canadian firm investing in Rosemont Mine by Tony Davis, Arizona Daily Star     8-30-2010

 

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   It Is Urgent that We Have a Strong Attendance at a Meeting Sponsored by Rosemont Copper on Tuesday, September 21, 2010, 6:30-8 p.m., Empire High School, 10701 E Mary Ann Cleveland Way, Vail   The following information is reproduced from a full page insert in a local eastside newspaper:    ************************************************************************************************************************************************ "Restoring the Land: Advances in Green Technologies for Mining Reclamation"   You are cordially invited to attend a forum discussing the newest efforts to preserve and restore the land during and after mining. Come hear about ongoing research, new state regulations and the role of cattle in mining reclamation.   Guest Speakers Joe Hart State of Arizona Mine Inspector   David Cook Owner of DC Cattle Co., LLC   Jeffrey Fehmi, PHD University of Arizona, School of Natural Resources ************************************************************************************************************************************************  It's very important that as many MEAA members as possible attend this meeting to challenge Rosemont's reclamation plans and claims.  Next week we'll send out a list of suggested questions to pose to the speakers.   Meetings on the Pima County ASARCO Draft Air Quality Permit Scheduled   The Pima County Department of Environmental Quality has scheduled two open houses to provide the public with information on the draft Air Quality Permits for the ASARCO Mission Mine in Sahuarita.   September 23, 2010, 5-7 p.m. Sahuarita Town Hall Council Chambers 375 W. Sahuarita Center Way, Sahuarita   October 14, 2010, 4:30-6:30 p.m. Joyner-Green Valley Public Library 601 North La Canada Dr., Green Valley   Jim Upchurch Appointed Coronado National Forest (CNF) Supervisor    A press release from Randy Moore, Regional Forester of the Pacific Southwest Region of the Forest Service, annouces that Inyo National Forest Supervisor Jim Upchurch has been promoted to the Forest Supervisor position of  the Coronado National Forest.  Mr. Upchurch arrived on the Inyo National Forest in October of  2007, after previously serving in Washington,  D.C.    At the Inyo he has overseen the completion of the Forest Motorized Travel Management project, the expansion of collaborative efforts with a variety of stakeholders, the implementation of new congressionally designated wilderness areas, and an increased in capacity for the forest through the further development of partnerships and cooperative work with other agencies such as BLM and the National Park Service.   He will arrive at the CNF on October 11, 2010.     Articles/Reports of Interest:   Rosemont's Optimism is Challenged by Tony Davis, Arizona Daily Star Endangered Species Act Protection Sought for Recently Discovered Orchid in Path of Proposed Rosemont Mine by Center for Biological Diversity   9-11-2010

 

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Don't Forget to Attend the Meeting Sponsored by Rosemont Copper on Tuesday, September 21, 2010, 6:30-8 p.m., Empire High School, 10701 E Mary Ann Cleveland Way, Vail    Following is a list of suggested questions related to Rosemont's reclamation plans and State of Arizona Mined Land Reclamation statutes that would be appropriate to ask the speakers at the meeting next Tuesday:   Q1:  What are the best examples of successfully reclaimed open pit copper mines in the state of Arizona with the same environment of terrain, climate, and vegetation as the Rosemont area?   Q2:  In June, 2009, Arizona State Mine Inspector Joe Hart received numerous requests to hold public meetings in Vail to hear questions, comments, and concerns regarding the proposed Rosemont reclamation plan.  Those requests from a community with one of the greatest exposures to the possible adverse impacts of the mine were denied.  In September, 2010, Mr. Hart is participating as a guest speaker at a Rosemont-sponsored public forum in Vail on the purported virtues of the new technologies that are the centerpiece of the Rosemont mine reclamation plan.  Why would Mr. Hart apparently have such low regard for the public's concerns, and such high regard for Rosemont's high profile public relations campaign?   Q3:  The Arizona State Mine Inspector Mined Land Reclamation Statutes state "In evaluating the reclamation plan, the inspector shall consider the technical and economic practicability of the proposed reclamation measures, taking into account the site-specific circumstances at the mining unit and the proposed post-mining land use objectives as stated in the reclamation plan."  How are technical and economic practicability defined and evaluated?   Q4:  The Arizona Administrative Code, when referring to mining unit reclamation standards, frequently applies a given standard only to the extent that a necessary reclamation measure is "technically and economically practicable."  Is this to say that a mine operator will be granted an exemption from a standard for an otherwise necessary reclamation measure simply because the mine operator has neither the technological nor financial means to carry out the measure?  Would it not be more reasonable to require the amendment of a mine plan of operations so that it would not include a proposed surface disturbance for which the mine operator has neither the technological nor financial means to satisfactorily reclaim?   Q5:  The Rosemont mine reclamation plan states:  "Because Rosemont Copper is planning concurrent reclamation of the facility, it is anticipated that the establishment of wildlife habitat and wildlife use will start early in the Project life."  What is the probability that the planned reclamation of the area disturbed by the Rosemont mine will not successfully reestablish the wildlife habitat and wildlife that existed in the area prior to construction of the mine?   Q6:  The Rosemont mine reclamation plan states that "much of the top and side surfaces of the Rosemont Ridge post-mining landform will be ideal for [cattle] grazing once vegetation is established.  What is the probability that the experimental revegetation plan for the area disturbed by the Rosemont mine will not be successful?  And, if the experimental revegetation plan is not successful, will not the absence of forage preclude the purported reclamation benefits of cattle grazing?   Q7:  The Arizona Administrative Code, referring to mining unit reclamation standards, states that "surface drainage patterns shall be restored to pre-mining conditions or new patterns shall be established."  What is the probability that surface drainage patterns will not be successfully restored to pre-mining conditions?   Q8:  The proposed Rosemont mine would include:  an open pit, a waste rock storage pile, a dry stack tailings pile, a heap acid leach pile, milling and shop facilities, offices, warehouses, and laboratories, utility corridors for water, roadways, and power, and buffer areas.  The total surface disturbance footprint of the mine would be in excess of 4,400 acres.  How many years will transpire between initiation of mine construction and conclusion of mine reclamation?   Q9:  What quantities of disturbed native soil excavated and conserved on site and non-native soil from off site will be required for the experimental revegetation plan?  And, where will the conserved soil be stockpiled?   Q10:  What financial contributions have been made to Arizona State Mine Inspector Joe Hart's election campaign by officials of Augusta Resource Corporation, Rosemont Copper Company, and others in the mining industry?   Q11:  What research support has Dr. Jeffrey Fehmi, University of Arizona, School of Natural Resources, received from Augusta Resource Corporation, Rosemont Copper Company, and others in the mining industry?   Q12:  What affiliations or associations does David Cook, owner of DC Cattle Company LLC, have with Augusta Resource Corporation, Rosemont Copper Company, and others in the mining industry?      Articles/Reports of Interest:   Hurdles on the Road to Mining: A Rosemont Mine update by Dick Kamp in Arizona Range News Supes' role in permit questioned by Greg Bryan in Arizona Daily Star     9-17-2010

 

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News    Scoping Notice: Plan of Operation for Mineral Exploration, Bear Canyon    The Coronado National Forest (CNF) is considering a request by Arizona Copper Corporation (AZ Copper) for approval of a plan of operations (PoO) to conduct a minerals exploration project in Bear Canyon, about 10 miles south of Sierra Vista.  Approval of the PoO would authorize AZ Copper to explore for minerals at five sites in the project area, each of which covers an area of 30 feet x 50 feet.   The Scoping Notice can be viewed on the CNF website.  Comments are due October 1, 2010.   Written comments may be sent by U.S. mail to Mr. Richard Ahern, Minerals Program Manager, Coronado National Forest, Supervisor's Office, 300 West Congress Street, Tucson, AZ 85701; by facsimile to his attention at (520) 388-8305; and by electronic mail (email) to http://comments-southwestern-coronado@fs.fed.us  Additional information about this project is available in an editorial in the Sierra Vista Herald: Our View: Mining Proposal a Concern.   Opportunity to Comment on the Coronado National Forest Proposed Changes in Motorized Travel System, Nogales Range District   The Coronado National Forest (CNF) has posted a Scoping Notice requesting comments on Proposed Changes In Motorized Travel System, Nogales Ranger District.  This is the first step of a National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA) review, providing the public with an opportunity to help the CNF identify issues and concerns related to the proposed action.   Written comments may be sent by October 18, 2010 by U.S. mail to Ms. Laura White, Travel Management Project Leader, Coronado National Forest, 300 West Congress Street, Tucson, AZ 85701; by facsimile to "ATTN: Nogales Travel Management NEPA" at (520) 388-8305; and by electronic mail (email) to comments-southwestern-coronado@fs.fed.us with "Nogales Travel Management NEPA" in the subject line.    Comments can also be made at a public open house to be hosted by the Forest on September 23, 2010, from 3:30 PM to 6:00 PM, at the Esplendor Resort located at 1069 Camino Caralampi in Rio Rico, Arizona.      Articles/Reports of Interest:   Rosemont Mine Simulation created by Jerry Caires for Save the Scenic Santa Ritas Rosemont radio ads: Call the supes by Tony Davis, Arizona Daily Star Candidate forum focuses on Rosemont, budget woes by Karen Walenga, Green Valley News Report argues Tucsonans value scenery more than their paychecks by Hugh Holub, Inside Tucson Business MEAA encourages comments on this one!     9-23-2010

 

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   ALERT: Problem with DEIS Postcards   This past week SWCA Environmental Consultants, Inc. sent postcards to anyone who has expressed an interest in receiving a copy of the proposed Rosemont Mine Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS).  The postcard asks you to select your preferred format (e.g. print, CD, download from website, etc.) for the DEIS when it is published.  There is a problem with the postcard as printed.  Respondents are instructed to fill out, detach, and return to SWCA the "Business Reply" section.  However, if you do this, your name and address will be separated from the response postcard, so SWCA will not know who sent it.   So, when responding, be sure to add your name and address in the space that is provided for supplying an alternate address.  It's possible that new postcards will be sent in the future, but we wanted you to be aware of the problem with the first ones mailed.   Rosemont Copper Reclamation Meeting on September 21, 2010    Portions of the Rosemont Copper Reclamation meeting held on September 21st are being posted to YouTube.  Following are links to an exchange with Arizona Mine Inspector, Joe Hart.  When additional postings are ready, we'll let you know.   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wj9mVCQX054 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABb4HNSoaPs  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwWeFVanbzU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kV9Fnj1DNoA   State Mine Inspector Candidate Interview   The two candidates for Arizona State Mine Inspector, Manuel Cruz and Joe Hart, were interviewed by Bill Buckmaster on September 23rd on Arizona Public Media.  A video of the interview is available for viewing at: http://ondemand.azpm.org/videoshorts/watch/2010/9/23/1321-who-will-be-arizonas-mine-inspector-for-the-next-four-years/?c=330   Please note that Joe Hart incorrectly states that the Rosemont Copper mine has been NEPA approved.   Articles/Reports of Interest:   Compromise is not a solution to Proposed Rosemont MIne by Leslie Kramer and Nancy McCoy in Inside Tucson Business County Wants More Rosemont Air Data by Tony Davis in Arizona Daily Star Letitia Cornacchia Appointed Vice-President, Investor Relations for the Augusta Group of Companies  press release on Google Finance.  Note that the release acknowledges that Wildcat is one of  the "Augusta Companies".  Wildcat owns 80% of the Hardshell mine project near Patagonia.   9-28-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News  Meet the Candidates, Saturday, October 9, 2010, 4:30-7 p.m., Walker Ranch, 88 Curly Horse Road, Sonoita    Plan to attend the Cienega-Santa Cruz Bi-Partisan Candidate Forum-Promoting Rural Awareness in Our Political Candidates. The forum will provide an opportunity to meet candidates for the Arizona Corporation Commission and Arizona Mine Inspector.  For directions and more information go to: http://rural30forum.blogspot.com/p/2010-cienega-santa-cruz-candidate-forum.html   DEIS Postcards   Corrected (green) postcards were sent this week to anyone who has expressed an interest in receiving a copy of the proposed Rosemont Mine Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS).  The postcard asks you to select your preferred format (e.g. print, CD, download from website, etc.) for the DEIS when it is published.  If you did not receive the card and wish to receive the DEIS, please contact mroth@fs.fed.us    Article/Reports of Interest   Mining, road issues await next Coronado forest chief by Dick Kamp in Sierra Vista Herald  Their Top 10: Rosemont, opponents tell all that's good, bad about mine by MEAA and Rosemont Copper in Green Valley News & Sun  MEAA members,we encourage you to write letters to the editor responding to Rosemont's statements.   10-7-10

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Tucson Electric Power Public Information Open House, Wednesday, November 17, 2010, 5:30 to 8:00 p.m., Rancho Resort Clubhouse, 15900 South Ranch Resort Blvd., Sahuarita   Plan to attend the Tucson Electric Power (TEP) public information open house scheduled for Wednesday, November 17th from 5:30 to 8:00 p.m. at the Rancho Resort Clubhouse, 15900 South Ranch Resort Blvd in Sahuarita.  At this meeting you will have an opportunity to hear a presentation (at 6:30 p.m.) about TEP's preferred route and four alternatives for the 138kV transmission line to bring power to the proposed Rosemont mine site if the mine is approved.   To view a map of the proposed and alternative routes and for more information about the meeting go to TEP's project website: http://www.tucsonelectric.com/Company/News/Rosemont/docs/Rosemont_Project_Newsletter_October_2010.pdf   SSSR Benefit, Tuesday, November 16, 2010, 6:30 p.m., Madera Clubhouse at Quail Creek, 2055 E. Quail Crossing Blvd., Green Valley   Help support Save the Scenic Santa Ritas (SSSR) by attending their benefit fundraiser on Tuesday, November 16th at the Madera Clubhouse at Quail Creek, 2055 E. Quail Crossing Blvd, Green Valley, starting at 6:30 p.m.  Enjoy an evening with David Yetman, host of The Desert Speaks, and Carl Perry, playing the Native American flutes he makes.  The event flyer is available at: http://www.scenicsantaritas.org/yetmanfundraiser/Yetman_flier.pdf   Support the Proposed Santa Cruz Valley National Heritage Area   Time is running out for Congressional approval of a Santa Cruz Valley National Heritage Area designation.  The U.S. Senate must vote on the Heritage Area bill or it will die at the end of the Congressional session in December.  Senators McCain and Kyl need to hear from us before they will actively support the Santa Cruz Valley National Area Act (HR 324).  Please email or call them today urging them to support this important legislation that will spur heritage-based economic development in our region.   More information, including talking points is available at: www.SantaCruzHeritage.org/Senate   Contact information for our Senators is:   Senator Kyl: 202-224-4521 (Washington office) or 520-575-8633 (Tucson office) or http://kyl.senate.gov/contact.cfm   Senator McCain: 202-224-2235 (Washington office) or 520-670-6334 (Tucson office) or http://mccain.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Contact.ContactForm   Articles/Reports of Interest    Letter from Pima County Administrator C. H. Huckleberry to Jim Upchurch, Coronado National Forest Supervisor,  providing an update on permitting and economics of the proposed Rosemont mine.   Plan for 2 pipelines would bring CAP water south by Philip Franchine in Green Valley News   Leave Santa Ritas as they are - that's not rabid corporate xenophobia  by Ray Carroll for Inside Tucson Business   In My View: Rosemont not good for GV by Rep. Gabrielle Giffords in Green Valley News

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Rosemont Mine Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) Delayed Again   Though not yet listed on the Coronado National Forest Rosemont EIS website, the Green Valley News and the Arizona Daily Star have announced that the DEIS for the proposed Rosemont Mine project, due to be released by December 2010, will not be released until an unspecified date in 2011.     Fairness of Environmental Impact Statement Process Challenged   Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, the Center for Biological Diversity, and Farmer's Insurance Co., have sent a letter to the Coronado National Forest notifying the CNF of "...violations of law in regards to the process of preparing the environmental impact statement (EIS) for the proposed Rosemont Mine. Specifically, the inclusion of Rosemont representatives on a regular and systematic basis in cooperating agency meetings is a violation of the Federal Advisory Committee Act, 5 U.S.C. App. II (FACA). Additionally, the Forest Service is in violation of the requirements of the Freedom of Information (FOIA) in regards to a response to a request filed by the Center for Biological Diversity on September 30, 2010."   The letter states that the Draft EIS "is now irreversibly tainted" and asks the Forest Service to remedy these problems by halting the EIS process and beginning it anew in full compliance with FACA. If Rosemont is to be a regular participant in cooperating agency meetings, the committee should be legally chartered as a Federal Advisory Committee with a balanced membership representative of all the various affected public interests including government, agriculture, tourism, business, communities, ranching, major water providers and users and other interests.  The letter also requests a response by January 14, 2011 with an explanation of how the FS intends to proceed. If satisfactory compliance with FACA and FOIA is not assured, CBD, SSSR and FICO will pursue their full range of legal options."    Additional information is available in an Arizona Daily Star article by Tony Davis.   Comments Requested by the Coronado National Forest (CNF) on Mining Exploration Projects North of Sonoita   Last week the Coronado National Forest sent out Scoping Notices for two mining exploration projects in the Santa Rita Mountains north of Sonoita:  Quartz Dreams and 5Amigos (5 Amigos map).   The notices request that comments for both projects be submitted by January 15, 2011.    MEAA wrote to Jim Upchurch, CNF Supervisor, requesting that the comment due date be reconsidered, since the release of these notices a few days before the Christmas and New Year holidays in essence left us with less than fifteen days to obtain meaningful input and comment.  We heard early this week that comments received by January 31, 2011, will be considered.  We'll provide suggested text for comments early in the coming weeks.   Mine, Mines, Everywhere   In addition to the two exploration projects mentioned above several other mine projects are in various stages of development in the Mountain Empire, as illustrated by the map below:           Happy New Year!   We wish all MEAA members a happy 2011!  Be prepared for a busy year of commenting and writing in order to protect and preserve our beautiful Mountain Empire.   12-30-2010

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News     Condolences and Get Well Wishes for Victims of the Attack on Representative Gabrielle Giffords   Words can't express the shock and sadness we feel as a result of the attack on Gabrielle Giffords, her staff, and constitutents.  We extend our deepest sympathy to the families of those who died in this senseless act of violence, and hope and pray for the full recovery of the injured.  Gabby and her staff have worked tirelessly on our behalf on the proposed Rosemont Mine review process, insuring that our voices are heard.   Response from the CNF to Fairness of Environmental Impact Statement Process Challenge   On January 14, 2011, the Coronado National Forest responded to the December 27, 2010, letter from Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, the Center for Biological Diversity, and Farmer's Investment Co., notifying the CNF of "...violations of law in regards to the process of preparing the environmental impact statement (EIS) for the proposed Rosemont Mine."   The CNF letter states that it has not violated the Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) or the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) during the Rosemont Copper NEPA process.    Additional information is available in an Arizona Daily Star article by Tony Davis.   Comments Due on January 31, 2011, on the Quartz Dreams and 5 Amigos Projects   In December the Coronado National Forest sent out Scoping Notices for two mineral exploration projects in the Santa Rita Mountains north of Sonoita:  Quartz Dreams and 5Amigos (5 Amigos map).   The CNF has informed MEAA that  comments received by January 31, 2011, will be considered.    We urge MEAA members to send comments to the CNF. Following are some points we recommend you include in your comments:   The Plan of Operations (PoO) is very general, thus making it difficult to provide informed comments on its potential effect on the environment.  Examples of lack of specificity in the PoO include:  The minerals that the Applicant believes are likely or expected to be discovered during the explorations are not identified  An estimation of the maximum number of excavation trenches to be dug or of the maximum size of the project site's footprint is not described. A statement as to whether or not the mineral concentrates extracted from the mine waste may be toxic and, if so, to what extent is not included. The cumulative impact of mine traffic on SR83 from all the proposed projects under consideration by the Coronado National Forest would be staggering if all operations are approved The processing equipment must be maintained and operated in such a manner so as to minimize the impacts of dust and noise production in the CNF and in the vicinity of any nearby residents. No information is provided on who will monitor the exploratory operations to insure compliance with safety requirements at the site and proper disposal of toxic waste and materials. No information is provided on reclamation actions once the exploration is completed.  The applicant should be required to post a reclamation bond to insure that the taxpayers do not become responsible for the cost of reclamation. Written comments may be sent by U.S. mail to Mr. Karl Sandwell-Weiss, Minerals Resource Geologist, Coronado National Forest, Supervisor's Office, 300 West Congress Street, Tucson, AZ 85701; by facsimile to his attention at (520) 388-8305; and by electronic mail (email) to comments-southwestern-coronado@fs.fed.us.   Articles/Reports of Interest   Canadian company plans silver mine near Patagonia by Tony Davis in Arizona Daily Star    Arizona plan for largest U.S. copper mine spurs economic, environmental debate by Kari Lydersen in The Washington Post   White House presses for new climate, wilderness protections by Juliet Eilperin in The Washington Post       1-19-2011

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Lawsuit Asks Federal Court to Ensure Public Interest is Represented in Proposed Rosemont Mine Process   In a lawsuit filed in Tucson on February 7, 2011 against the U.S. Forest Service, a business and conservation coalition asked a federal district court to halt the agency's violation of the law in its preparation of an "environmental impact statement" for the proposed Rosemont Mine in southeast Arizona's Santa Rita Mountains, expected to be published in draft form this month. The suit was filed by Save the Scenic Santa Ritas, the Center for Biological Diversity and Farmers Investment Co., a family-owned farm located near the site of the proposed mine.  Consult the full press release or complaint for more details about the lawsuit.   CAP Water in Green Valley: A Town Hall Forum, February 11, 2011, GVR West Social Center, 1111 Via Arco Iris, Green Valley, 1:30-3 p.m.   Hosted by the Green Valley Chamber of Commerce Environmental Committee the featured speakers include:  Ray Carroll, District 4 Pima County Supervisor Arizona Corporation Commission Representative Larry Dozier, Deputy Director Central Arizona Project (CAP) Bob Hedden, Chairman Green Valley Water District and Upper Santa Cruz Providers and Users Group Nan Walden, Vice President Farmers Investment Company (FICO) Virgil Davis, President Community Water    SSSR Public Forum on the Proposed Hardshell Mine, February 15, 2011, Cady Hall, 346 Duquesne, Patagonia, 5-6:30 p.m.   Save the Scenic Santa Ritas is holding a public forum on the proposed Hardshell Mine in Cady Hall in Patagonia on Tuesday, February 15th.  Following is the agenda:   5:00 pm Introductions by Gayle Hartmann, President of Save the Scenic Santa Ritas 5:10 pm Cliff Hirsch and Michael Stabile: what Chris Jones of Wildcat Silver has proposed for Hardshell mine activities. 5:25 pm  Annette Chavez, Sierra Vista District Ranger, Coronado National Forest will explain rules for mining on private and public land and Richard Ahern, Minerals Program Manager, Coronado National Forest, Tucson office. 5:45 pm Questions and Answers:  Panel: Cliff Hirsch, Michael Stabile, SSSR Board member Roger Featherstone, expert on mining issues and Jenny Neeley, attorney with Sky Island Alliance.  Moderator: Leslie Kramer, Sonoita attorney and SSSR board member 6:30 pm: Meeting adjourned   Articles/Reports of Interest:   Rosemont opponents sue over US-mine meetings by Tony Davis in Arizona Daily Star   County's $13,000 mine model by Tony Davis in Arizona Daily Star   Rosemont and Cheney challenged under same law by Dick Kamp in Willcox Range News   Officials provide information, answer questions about mine  by Adam Curtis in Sierra Vista Herald       2-9-11

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Listen to an Interview with Thomas Michael Power on KNST, 790 AM, Saturday, February 19, 2011, 12:05 p.m.   This Saturday, February 19th, Thomas Michael Power PhD, the consultant from Montana who prepared the MEAA economic study on the proposed Rosemont  mine, will be appearing as a guest on a local Tucson radio call-in /talk show "Mrs. Green's World".  The program airs at 12:05 (just past noon) on KNST, 790 AM.    In the past the show's hostess has had various Rosemont folks on the show, and some believe that the station has a pro-Rosemont bias, perhaps due to Rosemont as a station sponsor.  We expect that mine proponents are likely to call in, and we hope that MEAA members will listen and call-in with comments and questions.  Please take time to participate in this opportunity to support the idea and importance of "amenity-based economic development".     The announcement of this program appears on the show's website home page which can be accessed via the following link: http://www.mrsgreensworld.com/  The phone number to call-in  during her live broadcast is 520-880-5678. Please be prepared to counter questions or comments made by pro-Rosemont callers.   Take a Tour of Highway 83   Jim Kramp, Hilton Ranch Road Community, has created an excellent video describing the impact the proposed Rosemont Mine would have on Highway 83.  Join the tour of 83 at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onsYq0ggUsw   Articles/Reports of Interest:    Copper Capers a Mining Company's PR People Make another Gaffe by Tim Vanderpool in the Tucson Weekly   A Tale of Two CAP Pipelines: Rosemont Divides Local Water Powers by Philip Franchine in Green Valley News & Sun   2-17-11

Mountain Empire Action Alliance News   Listen to the KUAZ-FM (89.5) Series on Mining   We just received notice that an interview with several MEAA members conducted by Mark Duggan, Senior Radio News Reporter for Arizona Public Media, will air on Wednesday, March 16, 2011 at 6:33 a.m. with a repeat at 8:33 a.m.  This is the third broadcast in a series on mining.  The first broadcast, which provided an overview of copper mining in Arizona aired on Monday, March 14th.  The second is an interview with Rosemont CEO Rod Pace, which airs on Tuesday, March 15th.  All of the broadcasts will be made available for listening on the Arizona Public Media website.  Look for the audio playback bar or download  MP3 files of the broadcasts.    Our thanks go to the MEAA members who participated in this interview several months ago: Sarah Barchas, Wade Bunting, Don Byron, and Jimmy Pepper.     Articles/Reports of Interest:    The Grand Canyon Uranium Rush, editorial in the New York Times   Copper: Too Much, Too Little, Too Late?  Still and Economic Indicator?  by Michael Filighera in Seeking Alpha   3-15-11